From§Each

Page B56From§Each · the Justice & Legal book14 November to 15 November 2026

Justice & Legal

← B55Sealed · 14 November to 15 November 2026B57 →

Alaska keeps the ballot Trump called too confusing, then uses it to end 28 years of GOP governors.

Alaska's run of Republican governors died Friday, 28 years old, of complications from ranked-choice voting, cross-party loyalty, and a candidate recruitment effort the party could not get out of its own way.

It was born in 1998, the last time a Democrat held the governor's mansion in Juneau, and it is survived by the very ballot system a repeal measure tried, and failed, to kill this week.

In July, Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins, a 37-year-old former state lawmaker, spent four days and 450 miles down the Yukon River in a flat-bottomed skiff, passing through Deg Hit'an and Yup'ik villages on a campaign nobody in Juneau was counting yet. By 2 October, the Guardian was reporting that a Democratic upset was brewing in the governor's race as the president's approval numbers cratered nationally.

On 25 October, the president told reporters he was worried Alaska voters wouldn't understand what "incumbent" meant on a ranked-choice ballot — a complaint he had made before, about a system Alaskans had already voted, this same week, not to repeal. Three days later, on 28 October, Senator Lisa Murkowski crossed her own party's line and endorsed Kreiss-Tomkins over three Republican candidates, including Bernadette Wilson, the nominee the president had endorsed, saying Alaska needed a governor willing to work with both parties.

On Election Day, Alaskans voted to keep ranked-choice voting outright. In the four-way general the system produced, Kreiss-Tomkins defeated Wilson and two others to become the first Democrat elected governor of Alaska in more than twenty years.

The streak is preceded in death by no scandal and no single villain, only a ballot built to let voters rank what they actually wanted, and a senator willing to use it against her own party. It leaves behind a four-way race that worked exactly as drawn, and a repeal measure its own voters just buried alongside it.

In lieu of flowers, count every ranked choice on every ballot, the way the system was built to be counted.

The receipts (6)

DOJ's lawsuit for a narrow Sullivan loss watches Peltola pass his combined vote count entirely.

The chief laid the job on the table weeks ago: a Justice Department suit, built to block Alaska's certification, but only if the clause's one condition came true — a Republican loss, and a narrow one. On 23 October the order went out; on 24 October the suit went in, before a single Alaska ballot had been counted. The planner looked at the blueprint and admired the economy of it: a trigger with nothing attached to it yet, a pleading written for a result that didn't exist.

That was the easy part. The hard part, the part the crew has been watching since, is that the target the tool was built to hit keeps moving. On 10 November, Mary Peltola's lead over Senator Dan Sullivan stood at 2,517 first-choice votes, 48.63 to 47.47 percent — already wider than the 637-vote edge she had held the week before. The tinkerer, working the mechanism piece by piece, noted that the clause does not care how wide the gap gets; it only cares whether Sullivan lost. By 11 November it had lost worse: Peltola's total passed the combined count of both men on the ballot, the incumbent and the independent who shares his name, with her own share at 49 percent against the incumbent's 47.2. The muscle, who handles the part of the job where a bad premise gets taken apart, pointed out that a lawsuit keyed to a close call stops being a close-call lawsuit the moment the call stops being close.

Today's batch did not help the blueprint. The Associated Press has 98 percent of the vote counted and still has not called the race. Peltola's lead is now nearly four points, more than 10,000 votes, after the latest drop added her almost 2,000 votes in that one count alone. Peltola has repeatedly denied the ballot-stacking claims the suit implies, and a former Federal Election Commission chair told Fox News that prosecutions of Trump during the Biden administration set the precedent the Alaska probe is leaning on.

The pilot's job is to get the crew to the finish line. On this job, the finish line is a certification the race has not yet reached, for a race the tool was built to stop only if it came out the other way. It didn't.

The receipts (85)

Former prosecutor mourns 'entire process of justice' whose last official act was a failed execution

California's death penalty died this week, not by verdict but by signature, on a governor's way out of the building. No birth date is in the wire; the state will have to look that one up on its own. It is survived by 548 commuted sentences, a president calling the decision "a disaster for Justice in America," and a former deputy state attorney general calling it a betrayal of an entire process of justice.

The governor signed on a Thursday, November 5th. The order converted the sentences of the condemned to life without parole, and it did so, the Guardian reported, in a way that ensures none of the 548 can be executed under whichever governor comes next — a commutation built to outlive the man who wrote it. The Guardian's own count that day said "more than 500." An obituary's hardest line is usually the date of birth; this one's hardest line is the headcount, and that gap is not malarkey, it is paperwork nobody has finished.

One day after the signing, the Washington Examiner reported that the governor had acted unilaterally, rewriting hundreds of sentences against the will of California voters, timed to his last stretch in Sacramento. One day after that, a former deputy state attorney general took the complaint further in these pages: not a quarrel with one case or with 548 of them, but a betrayal of an entire process of justice, the commutations called "pompous" by someone who used to argue the state's capital cases for a living. This is not a gentle business, writing the obituary for a state's machinery. Some weeks the work is shit.

Seven days after that column ran, the president weighed in for the first time, on the record, calling the same decision "a disaster for Justice in America." A sitting president and a former prosecutor, writing the same complaint seven days apart about the same 548 names, and neither one named a single one of them.

In lieu of flowers, request the public file on the 548 commutations your state just signed. The names are a matter of record, and record-keeping is the only part of this process that survived.

The receipts (4)

Justice Department's lawsuit against an Alaska defeat that had not happened yet now has a defeat: 5,800 votes, uncertified, one of 24 races still uncalled.

The complaint has one strange word in it, and the word is if.

On Friday 23 October the president told reporters he had personally directed the Justice Department to go to court over Alaska's Senate race. The suit was filed on 24 October. It asks a federal judge to block certification of Alaska's Senate results should Senator Dan Sullivan, the Republican incumbent, lose to the Democrat, Mary Peltola. Not that he had. Common Dreams noted it was filed 12 days before the election.

All together now — the clause. It alleges no fraud. It names no ballot. Its theory is "voter confusion": Peltola's campaign, the Times reported, had recruited a second man named Dan Sullivan onto the ballot beside the senator, same name, different middle name. The president called the recruitment illegal and demanded the Democrat be disqualified. On the day of the filing the attorney general, Todd Blanche, declared the department would not "improperly" try to block states from certifying their elections. Common Dreams set the two events in one sentence and left them there.

That Friday, on Fox Business, a Washington Examiner columnist called the race "blatantly corrupt" and "a whole bowl of wrong." Politico reported the filing stunned officials in both parties. The Times' read on the department: "the president's instrument of unmediated executive power."

It was working two maps that week. Prosecutors sent letters to county registrars across California demanding they set aside and verify ballots the department said may belong to noncitizens; officials who did not comply, the letters said, "risk significant federal scrutiny." A judge, in those same days, ordered Homeland Security to stop sending agents door to door in nine states hunting voter fraud.

Alaska answered in writing on Saturday 31 October. Its lawyers' summary, as the Post carried it, ran three words: not even possible. On the same Saturday a former chairman of the Federal Election Commission, Hans von Spakovsky, told Fox News that Jack Smith's indictment of the president had set the precedent for the criminal probe in Alaska.

Then the voters. Senator Lisa Murkowski had already endorsed the Democrat running for governor, Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins, over the president's candidate, on 28 October. By 4 November at least six Republican seats had flipped and the chamber with them. In Mississippi the margin settled at 1,864 votes with 95 percent counted, Scott Colom ahead of Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith — the state's first Black senator since Reconstruction, if the number holds — and by 6 November lawyers for both sides were trading letters about counting procedure.

And in Alaska this week: Sullivan down 5,800 votes, one of 24 races still uncalled, nothing certified. All together now — the last line of the prayer: if he loses. He is losing.

The receipts (80)

Supreme Court blocked student IDs at New Hampshire polls two days after the state asked, citing a rule against changing election rules too close to the election.

I have been asked to walk you through the Supreme Court's week, and I am happy to, because the docket is short and the docket is clean.

Begin on September 14th, when the Court declined to let the administration enforce new mail-in ballot restrictions before the midterms. That is the Court telling the president no, and I would like that on the board before we go further, because on September 25th the same Court, six to three, lifted the order that had kept the Department of Homeland Security from using and expanding a database called the Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements to screen state voter rolls while the case runs on appeal. That database was built to check whether noncitizens qualified for government benefits. It is now being used to check whether citizens may vote, which is a different question from the one it was built to — I would like that back. It is the same question, put to a much larger file.

The ninety days is where people lose their footing. Existing law blocks most states from systematically purging voters from their rolls within ninety days of an election, and the Associated Press reported that the immediate impact of the order on these midterms was therefore likely limited. Limited. The window closes; the order does not. The order stands while the appeal runs, and the appeal runs as long as appeals run.

Common Dreams wrote that same Friday that the database is known for flagging naturalized citizens, and that eligible voters may be at risk of having their registrations wrongfully canceled weeks before the midterms. A flag is not a cancellation. A flag is a question. The voter answers the question and the voter votes. This paper printed on Sunday a count that the screen cannot confirm four in ten names, so call it four in ten questions, and I will concede that the word questions is doing more work than I hired it for.

Money, since someone always raises it. On September 22nd, Common Dreams reported that Elon Musk was reported to be planning at least $100 million for Republicans in these midterms, and reported critics questioning why Democrats aren't doing more to highlight it. On October 24th, The Lever traced the Israel lobby routing millions through groups promoting women, reproductive rights and Latino candidates, with AI interests adopting the method. None of that cancels a registration. Nothing in the week asks the money for a second form of identification.

Then New Hampshire. On October 20th, state officials filed an emergency petition to lift a last-minute block on their student ID ban. On Thursday the 22nd, the Court granted Secretary of State David Scanlan's application in a brief unsigned order, reversing a federal judge, citing the longstanding rule that lower federal courts should not "alter election rules" too close to election day, and warning of voter confusion. Justice Jackson dissented alone: "when an election is looming," she would not disturb a clearly justifiable federal-court order issued so the public gets accurate information.

This paper said that took twelve days. It said it twice, Sunday and Monday. The wire has the petition on the 20th and the order on the 22nd. Two days — and I notice I have just traded our number for a worse one.

Then November 5th, election eve: the Times reported the justices took just hours to reject the president's bid to meddle in the election. Hours for the president. Two days for the students. The rolls, for as long as the appeal takes.

The receipts (80)

Justice Department sued to block Alaska's certification if the Republican lost narrowly, then watched the margin grow to 5,800 votes.

The document at the center of this week is a complaint written in the subjunctive, and the subjunctive is the part worth your time. On 23 October the president told reporters he gave the order himself: "I'm the one that said, 'do it.'" On 24 October the Justice Department filed it in federal court, asking that the certification of Alaska's Senate race be blocked. Alaska had not yet counted a vote.

All together now — the condition. It does not fire because a race is close. It does not fire if the Democrat loses. It fires if Senator Dan Sullivan, the Republican incumbent, loses narrowly to Democrat Mary Peltola, and otherwise it waits in a drawer. The injury named is confusion, because a second man named Dan Sullivan appeared on the ballot. The pleading charges no fraud. It identifies no individual ballot. It is a lawsuit about one permitted outcome.

Alaska's own attorneys answered in a filing on Saturday 31 October. Setting those ballots aside was "both disturbing and impossible," they wrote, and there would be no way to do it without violating voter privacy. The ask was "not even possible." At a rally that Friday, Peltola said of the ballot-stacking reports: "I am so deeply offended by these accusations about having any involvement with anyone else's" — and did not mention the federal investigations. On Fox News that Saturday, a former Federal Election Commission chairman explained that the department's criminal probe had its precedent in the earlier indictment of the president.

Confusion, the pleading's one injury, developed a Republican problem on 28 October, when Senator Lisa Murkowski found the ballot clear enough to endorse the Democrat running for governor over the president's own endorsed candidate.

Then the count arrived. On 10 November, Peltola's lead stood at 2,517. By Friday it was 5,800 — past the senator's votes and his namesake's combined. The clause had already fired a second time in three weeks, in Mississippi, where by 4 November, with 95 percent counted, Scott Colom led Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith by 1,864 votes and lawyers for both sides were trading letters over counting procedure by 6 November. It lost there as well, to the man who became the state's first Black senator since Reconstruction.

Alaska closed the week by keeping the ranked ballot the president called confusing — the repeal measure failed — and then using it to end 28 years of Republican governors. The winner, Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins, spent four days in July covering 450 miles down the Yukon River in a flat-bottomed skiff, through Deg Hit'an and Yup'ik villages.

The department's interest in ballots held back was not limited to Alaska. On 24 October federal prosecutors wrote county registrars across California demanding that ballots be set aside and verified as possibly belonging to noncitizens; offices that failed to comply, the letters said, risk significant federal scrutiny. In Los Angeles the federal prosecutor put the stakes this way: "Every minute that goes by, American citizen votes are being diluted in the state of California." The door-knocking had its own answer — on 24 October a judge ordered Homeland Security to stop sending agents into nine states to hunt voter fraud.

The week's other election-security story, on 60 Minutes, concerned a former Colorado election official convicted over breaching the voting system she swore to protect, who served less than two years and for whom the president has gone to extraordinary lengths. She maintains she was showing flaws in the system.

One more time, all together — the condition. The voters have now supplied the other half of it twice.

The receipts (80)

Supreme Court, six to three, gave Homeland Security ninety days to screen voter rolls with a database that cannot confirm four in ten names.

I will defend this Court on the merits, and the merits are a calendar.

Start with September 14th, which your side never starts with: the justices declined to let the administration enforce its new mail-in ballot restrictions before the midterms. That is the administration losing. Hold on to that.

Then September 25th. Six to three, the Court lifted the lower-court order that had kept the Department of Homeland Security from using and expanding a database called SAVE to screen state voter rolls, and gave the department ninety days to do it. SAVE was built to check whether noncitizens qualified for benefits. It is known for flagging naturalized citizens. It cannot confirm four in ten names. The word is screening. Screening is not purging. Screening is a courtesy.

And the courtesy was capped, which is the part nobody reads. Existing law blocks most states from systematically purging voters inside ninety days of an election, which is why the Associated Press reported the immediate impact on the midterms was likely limited. Limited. Note the two clocks, because they do not run the same direction: the department's ninety days to build the thing counts forward from the order and runs past Election Day, while the ninety days of protection counted backward from Election Day, and Election Day came and went. So the tool is new and the shield is — I would like to come back to that.

Money, briefly, since you will raise it. In September the reporting had one donor planning to spend at least $100 million for Republican majorities, and the critics spent that week rebuking Democrats for declining to make an issue of it. Those are filings. Every dollar disclosed, on the record, by law. The fact that we can count it is the proof the system works, and the count is three hundred sixty-six million dollars, which is not a defense, it is a number, and I said it out loud.

New Hampshire. The state's secretary of state filed an emergency application on October 20th. The Court granted it that Thursday in a brief unsigned order, citing the longstanding rule that lower federal courts should not "alter election rules" too close to Election Day. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented alone, writing that "when an election is looming" she would not disturb a justifiable federal-court order meant to keep the public accurately informed. One of nine. Republicans said the ban was needed to combat fraud. The Federalist called the student card a loophole. Voting-rights advocates said the directive falls on young and low-income voters, who are, let us be precise about this, voters.

Then election eve, and the rebuke. The president asked the justices to step into the election, and they took just hours to reject it. Hours. That is independence and I will stack it against anything you have.

Twelve days for the students. Hours for the president. Ninety days for the database, still running, with nothing counting backward at it now.

And this same Court has not decided whether a person may sue the officer who hurt them.

The receipts (80)

WARNED FOR YEARS

FAA predicts collapse, asks for $30 billion, collapses anyway, doubles the ask to $50 billion.

The possibility that the Federal Aviation Administration did not see this coming died this weekend, survived by the paperwork that proves it did. Born September 28, when Secretary Sean Duffy and Administrator Bryan Bedford stood at Reagan National and introduced the Modern Skies Act, asking Congress for $30 billion to modernize the air traffic control system before whatever it was built to prevent could happen.

The warning arrived early and from abroad. On September 9, Britain's air navigation service canceled or delayed thousands of flights at fifteen airports after what the wire described as a technical issue — the kind of failure a modernized system is supposed to absorb without grounding a country. On Friday, the FAA's communications system went down for a fourth time in two months and grounded every departing flight in the country, the third stop of its kind on record, more than 1.5 million travelers held at the gate. Secretary Duffy called it "a communication issue impacting all Air Route Traffic Control Centers." The agency's own alert cited "extraordinary circumstances."

By Saturday, House Speaker Mike Johnson had the closing argument ready, telling Fox News's Saturday in America that "we don't really need any investigation ... we need further investment" — settling the question of why before anyone outside the agency had been asked to answer it. Investigation, in his telling, is malarkey; investment is the only remedy, and the remedy's price keeps changing.

The bill for not asking why got bigger. Air traffic controllers had a different answer. Sixty of them, interviewed by a Washington Examiner reporter, said they did not believe Duffy's account of what had actually happened.

Then, Sunday, the file came out. The Washington Post reported the agency had been warned for years that a failure exactly like this one was coming, and that officials traced Friday's cancellation of more than 12,000 flights to the installation of a single new router. Years of warning, one router, and $20 billion added to the invoice between the warning's filing date and its bill.

Preceded in death by the $30 billion estimate. Survived by its successor, and whatever number succeeds that.

In lieu of flowers, the family asks that Congress read the file before it signs the check.

The receipts (87)

← B55Sealed · 14 November to 15 November 2026B57 →

Every page of the Justice & Legal book → · All the books