From§Each

Page B57From§Each · the Justice & Legal book15 November to 20 November 2026

Justice & Legal

← B56Open · 6 of 8 storiesB58 opens when this page fills

Justice Department sued to block a narrow Sullivan loss; Alaska's margin grew to 5,800 votes.

The complaint sitting in federal court was drafted for one result: Senator Dan Sullivan, the Republican incumbent, loses to Democrat Mary Peltola, and loses narrowly. The Justice Department's suit to block certification of Alaska's Senate race fires only on that condition. Everything since the filing has been the vote count answering it, number by number, hon.

On 30 October, Washington was still arguing procedure before Alaska finished counting: a ballot-stacking controversy around Peltola's candidacy, the Hill reported, already had Senate Majority Leader John Thune facing questions about whether he would seat her if she won at all. Two days later, on NBC's "Meet the Press," Senator Tim Scott was asked whether he would accept Alaska's results if Peltola won. He would not say yes. That same Sunday, a federal judge threw the Justice Department's suit out. The administration said it would appeal anyway, and the Guardian reported the suit had been filed at the president's direction in the first place.

By 4 November, the wire service was already filing for the long game: the outcome, CBS reported, "could take weeks to determine" — complicated on the ballot itself by a second candidate who also happens to be named Dan Sullivan.

The count did not slow down. On 6 November, a parallel filing turned up in Mississippi: Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith demanded ballot preservation in that state's Senate race, and Democrat Ty Colom called it an "unlawful attack"; his lead widened anyway that week, the same week Alaska's widened too. By 10 November, Peltola's lead over Sullivan had grown again. By 11 November, her vote count passed the combined total of both men named Dan Sullivan, the incumbent and the spoiler together — the same date Mississippi's race was independently reported leaning Democratic, the same arithmetic running twice. On 14 November, the New York Times laid out the ranked-choice mechanics producing the number.

That number, as of today, is 5,800 votes. The same wire item that ran on 4 November ran again this week, word for word: the outcome could take weeks to determine. The race is one of 24 Senate and House contests still uncalled nationally, twelve days after the polls closed — a timeline the October filing did not account for, and a margin its drafters did not have in front of them when they wrote the word "narrowly."

The receipts (85)

Mamdani disbands a unit unions warn is too dangerous to lose; Florida hires its officers the same day.

The Strategic Response Group died Monday, of a promise kept. It was born, as these units are, out of some predecessor's need to look serious about the street, and it is survived by a new Community Safety Division, which inherits its caseload and, for now, not its name.

Preceded in death by its own rebranding. On Nov. 13, three days before the end, the Post reported City Hall intended to rename the unit rather than close it, after criticism from inside the mayor's own party. A mayor who built a career promising to end the unit floated giving it new letterhead instead. The rebrand did not survive the weekend.

The file on how it got to Monday runs back weeks. On Sept. 29, Politico reported Mayor Mamdani had quietly required his own office's sign-off before the unit could make arrests at a protest — a mayor regulating a thing he had not yet agreed to end. On Oct. 12, the Post reported members of his own party pressing him to fire Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch and disband the unit outright, after a shooting involving immigration agents. On Oct. 18, Mamdani directed the department to conduct what his office called a comprehensive review of its use-of-force policies, a study ordered while the unit still stood. On Oct. 30, Fight Back News reported more than sixty people had rallied outside Brooklyn Central Court for over 14 hours after the unit arrested two organizers; both were released from jail. On Nov. 12, Fox News reported Mamdani was finally preparing to do the thing he had promised to do all along.

Monday, he did it. The Daily Caller ran a column warning the pullback would hand the street to the same movements other cities lost control of after similar moves. Florida's Sen. Ashley Moody, writing the same day, suggested the officers it leaves behind might find a home in her state's law enforcement agencies — a second career for a unit one party just finished calling a threat to public safety.

In lieu of flowers, the department is asked to release the use-of-force review Mayor Mamdani ordered a month ago, and let the public read it before the next unit gets a name.

The receipts (9)

Congresswoman tells Homeland Security secretary "you are killing people"; court answers next day: up to 17 years.

I need someone to explain something to me, and I figure the only ones equipped to do it are the ones who wrote it. The court, I mean. They do this for a living. I don't.

Here's what's on the page, best I can tell. Thursday, the Third Circuit told Representative LaMonica McIver her charges over the scuffle outside the detention facility stand — no dismissal. Same court, same day, a second line further down the docket: the full bench declines to rehear that ruling either. Both dated the same Thursday. Is that two separate decisions from that building, or one answer that came out wearing two headlines?

I went looking for whether a court's full bench turning down a rehearing like that had happened anywhere else lately, because the shape of it looked familiar. It had. Back on August 28th, a different appeals court, the D.C. Circuit, turned down Peter Navarro's request to have the full court rehear his contempt conviction. No judge even asked for a vote, the order said. The paper covering it, the Washington Examiner, put this in their own headline, their words, not mine: "Always headed to Supreme Court." I wrote that down exact, quotation marks included, because the last thing I want is to hand somebody a word that isn't theirs. Two different circuits, two full benches, twelve weeks apart. Twice. Is that enough to earn the word pattern, or does it take a third?

Here's the part I can't work out without help. Thirteen days after that Navarro denial — September 10th — a different appeals court, the Fourth Circuit, ruled the other direction on a related question. Rejected the government's detention policy outright, 2 to 1, and the majority brought up the Japanese internment camps to explain the vote. Thirteen days between one appeals court closing a door on a second look and a different one opening a different door most of the way. One ruling ran long enough to reach back to World War Two for its reasoning. The other didn't need a page past "denied." Is that the law being different, or the case being different?

I was in the garage this weekend — the car's been running rough, needs a belt — with the dog parked in the doorway the way he does, turning the McIver piece over while I had my hands in the engine. Fox News called Thursday's ruling a "key win" — I want to be careful here, because I had it wrong on my first pass, wrote "a key win," had to cross it out — it's "key win," no article, that's their headline, exact. She's facing up to seventeen years for that scuffle, outside a facility she went to on an oversight visit back in May of 2025 — a year and a half ago now, I had the date wrong too before I checked. The day before Thursday's ruling, she told the Homeland Security secretary, to his face: "You are killing people." Then the court ruled again.

Hang on — before I let the court go, since I've got the page still open — one more thing. Two denials to McIver, same Thursday. When the same federal appeals system hands the same kind of no to two different people, charged with two different things, inside one short stretch of months, is there a word the court would use instead of twice?

The receipts (5)

THE WITHDRAWAL

DOJ drops its lawsuit, written to fire only on a narrow GOP loss, now losing by 5,800 votes.

Today we are making a lawsuit written to fire on only one result of an election, not a dish you get over here, where the count simply runs to its end and stops. The Justice Department filed this before Alaska finished voting, built to block certification if Senator Dan Sullivan, the Republican, lost to Democrat Mary Peltola — and this week asked the same appeals court to drop its own case, calling it "moot."

You will need two men named Dan Sullivan on one ballot, the Alaska Supreme Court's ruling the second one's candidacy was legal, and the president's sentence to reporters on 23 October: "I'm the one that said do it." Turn it over and look underneath: it is an order, with a condition attached — it fires only if the first Sullivan loses narrowly.

CLIVE: An order, not an opinion. Mine arrive the same way; I have been drafting mine in verse since April, and a verdict is still a verdict even when it rhymes.

ROB: Rhyming's one thing. The hot water's been off since the weather turned, and I've heard no couplet about that — only about a man whose name turned out to need two of him.

The department did as it was told, and it went on the floor once already: on 2 November the Guardian reported a judge had dismissed the suit the Sunday before, the administration saying it meant to appeal. A suit built to fire on one outcome will not survive the other.

KEITH: Cooking to a single result — there's money in that. I could sell "depends who wins" in a tin to a few councils by Thursday.

By 10 November the Hill had her lead expanding; by the 11th she had passed not one Sullivan's vote total but both combined, after the count's latest drop. The margin kept climbing past 5,800 votes — a good deal more than narrow, however the word is used.

ROB: A good deal more than narrow — that's the rota, that is. The washing-up isn't narrowly undone; it's undone by a mile, missing since the schedule vanished.

This week, with the win no longer close enough to meet its own condition, the department did what the arithmetic left it: on Thursday it asked the appeals court to dismiss the suit it filed before voting began. The New York Times notes only that critics had called the suit meritless from the start.

The Guardian, which is what they have here, prints this as the administration moving "to drop legal challenge to Mary Peltola's Alaska Senate win." At home the department's own filing calls the same thing "moot."

This one serves no one: a suit built to fire on one outcome never got to fire, and the department withdraws a case critics had already called meritless. Sullivan's loss stands; nothing here says certification itself is finished.

GARY: Nothing's finished. I've been saying that about the kitchen door for ages, and I'm taking it off its hinges tonight whether anyone's finished with it or not.

The receipts (86)

Gore warned 'serious mistake'; Senate passed the bill a day later; The Hill named the fourteen Democrats today.

The environmental review this country built to decide where a pipe goes, where a line gets strung, where a data center gets poured into concrete — the paperwork a company has had to clear before it digs — is survived, as of Thursday night, by a faster clock.

On 1 October the bill got its name, the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, and its sales pitch: speed the buildout, lower the bills. On 22 October an analysis read past the pitch and found the bill would lock in approvals already granted to fossil fuel plants and data centers under the last administration, a fast lane paved before the vote ever happened. By 9 November the Guardian found the people who watch this kind of bill torn over it, same statute, same fence, standing on both sides. On 16 November Al Gore called passing it a "serious mistake." The Senate heard him and kept moving. On 17 November, 21 members of the Democratic caucus joined Republicans to end debate.

By Thursday the bill was the floor's business, 62 to 33. Thirty-one Democrats voted no, more opposition in one party than the other party cast in full. Two Republicans joined them. The label on the bill says bipartisan. The arithmetic underneath it leans one way, and on Friday The Hill printed the arithmetic by name: fourteen Democratic senators supplied the votes the bill needed to clear sixty-two. The bill loosens the review that law once required; it does not erase that review everywhere — the wire copy never claims that much, and no penny-ante hedging about "safeguards" changes what got shorter here.

It is shit to watch a safeguard get timed out in public, calmly, by members of both parties. They did it without raising a voice.

Survived by: the House, where the bill goes next.

In lieu of flowers, ask your own senator, by name, which vote on that list was theirs.

The receipts (4)

Trump's arch: three lawsuits, two court orders, zero dollars appropriated.

ROY: A panel of his own appointees waved through a 250-foot arch Congress has not funded. A judge stopped work before midnight the same day. Two weeks later a second judge calls it a rushed job. Judges are doing the budgeting. I am so sick of this bullshit.

LOIS: Judge Brinkema, Friday: a preliminary injunction, the project a rushed job with no legal basis — the Guardian. A federal judge halted the work before midnight on November 6th, the day the panel approved it. Arlington County sued October 9th, DC and Virginia October 31st. Still no appropriation.

The receipts (82)

← B56Open · 6 of 8 storiesB58 opens when this page fills

Every page of the Justice & Legal book → · All the books