“CDC, Pennsylvania's growing feud over measles: 4 things to know”, 3 September 2026 (Photo via The Hill — the original report)
As it ran on the front
Pennsylvania's Department of Health announced on August 25 that measles had done something it hadn't done in that state in 35 years: it killed someone. Two people, both unvaccinated, both Lancaster County residents, one of them an infant. Secretary Debra Bogen noted the disease had been "largely eliminated" for more than three decades — her word, about a virus that just got two names attached to it.
By August 26, Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. was in an online feud with Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro over the announcement. Not over the nearly 400 measles cases the state has logged so far this year. Over whether Shapiro had described the two deaths correctly.…
…(cont) The next day it went national. Dr. Mehmet Oz, administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, told Fox Business, "We don't know exactly what happened in Pennsylvania yet. We don't know if the children died..." Call it caution if you want — a careful clinician's instinct not to speculate on cause of death without the full record. Except he wasn't asked to speculate. He was asked to confirm two people were dead, and there is no delicate way to finish that sentence, so he didn't.
On August 28, Kennedy was back, seizing on what The Hill called "vague information" from Shapiro to question the same two deaths a second time. Not new information. The same infant, asked about again.
Nine days after Pennsylvania's announcement, four news cycles deep, the CDC still hasn't added the two deaths to its national count, and has instead gone public questioning the state health department's own findings, according to today's rundown. That is due diligence, technically — verification, process, protocol, all the words that make delay sound like rigor. It is also, four news cycles later, still no shots in Lancaster County arms and still no federal number that matches Pennsylvania's.
It has now been exactly one week — not more, exactly — since the government's own Medicare administrator went on cable news and could not confirm a child had died. A week is long enough to confirm a death certificate. It has apparently not been long enough to confirm that a 35-year run without a single measles death just ended, or that the number a health department owes the public is shots administered, not a body count still under review.
🍺
“They're not disputing that measles killed two people, they're disputing who gets to say so first. Robert Kennedy runs the federal health department and his first move on a dead infant was to pick a fight with the governor instead of the vaccination rate. Nine days, four news cycles, and the CDC still won't put two dead Pennsylvanians on its own count — that's not caution, that's a number somebody doesn't want to publish.”
“Nobody's saying the deaths aren't real, we're saying the process to confirm cause of death has to be rigorous, that's just good science — Dr. Oz was very clear on Fox Business that we don't know if the children — okay, I need to stop reading that quote out loud, it's not landing the way I want it to.”
The US declared measles eliminated in 2000. The last two years carry more cases than the rest of the century combined - the worst count since 1991 The Hill / CDC measles data, July 2026
The Pennsylvania Department of Health on Tuesday announced that the state recently suffered its first two measles-related deaths in 35 years. The two individuals who died were unvaccinated residents of Lancaster County, according to…
Click in for more news from The Hill {beacon} Healthcare Healthcare The Big Story Kennedy feuds with Shapiro over vaccines An online row between Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro…
The US declared measles eliminated in 2000. The last two years carry more cases than the rest of the century combined - the worst count since 1991 The Hill / CDC measles data, July 2026
Click in for more news from The Hill {beacon} Healthcare Healthcare The Big Story RFK Jr. seizes on Shapiro's measles statements Top Trump administration health officials are seizing on vague information from Pennsylvania to openly…
The US declared measles eliminated in 2000. The last two years carry more cases than the rest of the century combined - the worst count since 1991 The Hill / CDC measles data, July 2026
Top Trump administration health officials are openly questioning the circumstances of two deaths that Pennsylvania officials attributed to measles. “We don't know exactly what happened in Pennsylvania yet,” Dr. Mehmet Oz, administrator of…
Pennsylvania health officials last week announced two unvaccinated people died from measles-associated conditions, including an infant. But the announcement was just the beginning of a growing political controversy that’s pitting the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) against the state’s health department. The agency is…