A judge revealed he intends to declare a mistrial in Lindsay Clancy's murder trial Friday on the seventh day of deliberations -- but gave her defiant lawyer just one hour to file an emergency appeal against the ruling.
Page A3From§Eachthe matinee edition — 4 September 2026
Clancy mistrial declared, then paused for a Hail Mary, then explained live for the home audience

First, the judge in the Lindsay Clancy case announced he would declare a mistrial. That should be simple, but in this age of wall-to-wall coverage, nothing is. The press wires went live, feeding out the news in real time (3). But instead of a hard stop, the judge granted the defense a one-hour window to appeal his own decision (5, 6), a twist that left the legal process open and a nation of viewers waiting. The New York Post and NBC News both called the emergency appeal a 'Hail Mary,' a phrase that could describe the entire proceeding. With the courtroom's next move paused, the networks moved in to fill the gap, rolling out live explanations of the possible outcomes for those keeping score at home (21). And when the defense demanded the mistrial declaration be stayed (26), the story became not just what the verdict was, but when — and how — it would become real. The American justice system’s transparency now means every pause, exception, and procedural twist is not just a matter of record, but a matter of live broadcast, with every step analyzed in real time, until the judge — or the networks — finally call it finished.
“Only in America does a mistrial come with a halftime show and live color commentary. The judge can't finish the call before the defense gets one more shot, and the networks are rolling out the play-by-play like it's the Super Bowl. Feels like the justice system's last act is always a press conference.”
“The process is working exactly as intended. Transparency is the hallmark of our legal system — that's why the public deserves to see every possible outcome, as it unfolds, with expert analysis and time for the defense to, well, briefly appeal the decision before it's finalized. This is all perfectly normal and...did I say that? I meant, it's complicated.”
The receipts
The judge in the Lindsay Clancy murder case announced Friday he was declaring a mistrial after jurors were unable to reach a unanimous verdict. However, when defense attorney Kevin Reddington requested an immediate stay of the declaration, the judge gave the defense one hour to appeal.
Lindsay Clancy's lawyer claimed in court that one juror in the killer mom's murder trial "refuses to listen to the law."
A Massachusetts judge said he would declare a mistrial Friday after the jury weighing the fate of Lindsay Clancy failed for the third time to reach a verdict in the case of the mother accused of the strangling deaths of her three young children in 2023.
24/7 coverage of breaking news and live events
This page is a back-issue: the story as it ran, receipts as they were. The current edition is at the front.