Lindsay Clancy's attorney, Kevin Reddington, has filed an emergency appeal before the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts to prevent Plymouth Superior Court Judge William Sullivan from calling a mistrial. CBS News' Shanelle Kaul reports.
Page A8From§Eachthe matinee edition — 4 September 2026
Clancy trial declared mistrial, then delayed, then appealed, then declared mistrial again, then delayed again

The Lindsay Clancy murder trial has gone from open-and-shut to a procedural Möbius strip, never quite reaching a verdict or closure. First, the judge indicates a mistrial, a move that would typically end proceedings. But instead of wrapping up, an emergency delay is approved, pressing pause on the process. Next, live updates highlight that strong jobs numbers might delay a rate cut, but more importantly, the judge is still 'ready' to declare a mistrial, as if the button is half-pressed. That declaration comes, but not before another emergency delay is allowed. The defense files an emergency appeal, and the judge, undeterred by the appeals and delays already stacked up, says he'll declare a mistrial again. The case is in limbo, the process apparently never-ending, with each legal maneuver opening another door back into the same courtroom. For most people, a mistrial means start over or walk away; here, it just means circle the block and hope for new paperwork. The only thing moving forward is the legal bill, and the only clear verdict is that the system protects procedure over resolution. Justice delayed is justice denied, but here, it's justice put on repeat.
“They keep calling it a mistrial, but it isn't over—every time the judge says it's done, somebody hits pause and starts it back up again. If you or I tried this many do-overs in court, they'd call it contempt. Justice is on an endless loop, and the only ones getting anywhere are the lawyers billing by the hour.”
“It's important to ensure the process is fair—sometimes, that means a mistrial; sometimes, an emergency delay; sometimes an appeal. The fact that it keeps getting delayed just shows how careful and conscientious everyone is being, and, uh, the wheels of justice sometimes need to spin in place. Did I say process? I meant progress.”
The receipts
A mistrial was declared in Lindsay Clancy's murder trial in Massachusetts Friday, but the judge granted her attorney an emergency stay.
A judge indicated the Lindsay Clancy murder trial would end in a mistrial Friday, then gave the defense a one-hour delay to make a plea to the state's highest court.
For the third time since deliberations began, jurors in Clancy’s trial reported being unable to come to a consensus.
The U.S. economy added 162,000 jobs last month, a stronger-than-expected showing. And now President Trump wants to see interest rates dropped, threatening to cut off trade with several countries if the Federal Reserve doesn’t budge at its September meeting.
This page is a back-issue: the story as it ran, receipts as they were. The current edition is at the front.