Mr. Pappas, a moderate Democrat who has served four terms in the House, will face former Senator John E. Sununu, the Republican nominee, in November.
Page A3From§Eachthe late evening edition — 8 September 2026
Democratic 'socialism panic' produces landslide for the progressive, then landslide for the moderate, seven days apart.

As it ran on the front
The panic began thirteen days before New Hampshire voted. On August 27th, the Washington Examiner reported that Karishma Manzur, a socialist, had closed a fifty-point gap on Chris Pappas, the four-term congressman who had already locked up major endorsements and cleared the field of potential challengers, warning that the "national insurgency" beating establishment Democrats elsewhere was now coming for the Granite State. The next day, Sen. John Fetterman gave the panic its name, telling The Hill the Democratic Party has "a socialism problem" — citing Abdul El-Sayed's Senate campaign in Michigan and Graham Platner's exit from the Maine race. New Hampshire was not in that sentence. It did not need to be; the label was already loose in the wires, a diagnosis applied before anyone examined the patient.
Five days later, on September 2nd, the theory got its first test. Massachusetts held its own Senate primary: Sen. Ed Markey, the twenty-term progressive incumbent, against Rep. Seth Moulton, the moderate running on generational change. The Hill's own account of the race called it a "flipped dynamic" compared to the showdowns making national news — here the progressive was the safe bet and the moderate was the insurgent. Markey won anyway, "easily routing his rival," per that same reporting. A landslide. For the socialist wing of the argument.…
…(cont) Seven days after that, in New Hampshire, Pappas did the same thing in reverse. The New York Times filed it flat: "Chris Pappas Defeats Progressive Challenger in New Hampshire Senate Primary." Fox News's headline read: "Establishment Dem defeats socialist challenger in crucial battleground Senate primary." Another landslide. For the establishment wing of the same argument.
Run the tape straight through and the "socialism problem" stops looking like a finding and starts looking like a template, stapled onto whichever primary comes next regardless of which side is set to win it. Massachusetts broke the frame seven days before New Hampshire broke it again, in the opposite direction — two landslides, one narrative, filed before either result had a direction to confirm it. Pappas now moves on to face John Sununu, a former senator, in the fight Republicans actually wanted. The one about socialism was there to fill the two weeks before it.
“They ran thirteen days of wire copy warning the Democratic Party had a socialism problem, and both times anyone actually counted votes, whoever already held the institutional edge won by a landslide — the progressive incumbent in Massachusetts, the establishment congressman in New Hampshire, seven days apart, in opposite directions. That's not a socialism problem, that's an incumbency problem wearing a costume. Pappas moves on to the real fight, against a former senator the party actually needs to worry about, while those thirteen days of panic just filled the space until it started.”
“Look, the socialism problem is real — Senator Fetterman said it himself, and he's a Democrat, so that's basically bipartisan confirmation. Sure, he was talking about Michigan and Maine and never once mentioned New Hampshire, but the pattern was obviously about to repeat there too, everybody could see it coming, that's just — wait, did I just call something "obvious" that didn't happen? That's not a talking point, that's just a vibe we ran with for two weeks.”
The receipts
Chris Pappas defeated Karishma Manzur in the New Hampshire Senate primary, but a heated general election awaits against a former U.S. senator.
Rep. Chris Pappas (D) and former Sen. John E.
· Socialist surge threatens Democrats in New Hampshire Senate race from the morgue, 27 Aug 2026
· Fetterman: Democratic Party has 'socialism problem' from the morgue, 28 Aug 2026
· Markey defeats Moulton in Massachusetts Democratic Senate primary from the morgue, 2 Sep 2026
· Markey shrugs off Moulton in generational clash: 3 takeaways from Massachusetts primaries from the morgue, 2 Sep 2026
This page is a back-issue: the story as it ran, receipts as they were. The current edition is at the front.