From§Each

Page A2From§Eachthe midnight edition — 12 September 2026

DeSantis offers asylum to holdout juror days after their own domestic violence record surfaces

“DeSantis: 'Florida will provide asylum' to holdout juror in Lindsay Clancy case”, 12 September 2026 (Photo via The Hill — the original report)

As it ran on the front

I want to say something nice about this one, because nobody does anymore. Governor DeSantis's statement Friday used the word "asylum" for the holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy case, and as a piece of writing, that's a strong choice. Asylum is a serious word. It's the word for somebody running from something dangerous, and somebody in Tallahassee sat with it a while before they used it on a juror. I respect the craft. Then I looked at the date on the statement — September 12th — and the date on the NBC Boston story about the same juror's own restraining order — September 11th. I wrote both dates down on the same scrap of paper that lives on my car visor now, since the glovebox gave out around the Clinton administration, and I've been staring at that scrap since.

I'm sorry, I keep going back to those two dates, but here's the question they leave me with: which came first — the story about their history, or the offer of asylum?…

…(cont) I'm sorry, let me try it from a different side, because the calendar isn't the only way in. This jury split eleven to one. That's on the record — the foreperson's note, the judge pulling the holdout aside on day seven to ask them, on the record, about their reasonable doubt. A whole country spent a week admiring the one. Then the court file turned up a different kind of "one" attached to that same person — one restraining order, the kind a court doesn't issue over a parking dispute. Does the word "asylum" appear anywhere in that court file, or only in the governor's statement about it?

I apologize, I know I've now brought this up twice, but there's a third side to it that bothers me more than the first two. The Daily Caller called what happened to this juror doxxing. The Federalist called it badgering. A Fox newsletter ran this case next to Kohberger and the Menendez brothers, filed under true crime, ripped fresh from the headlines. Four outlets, one week, and every one of them had a word ready for what the jury and the press supposedly did to this juror. How many of those same outlets had a word ready, that same week, for what a court file says they'd done to somebody else?

I'm sorry, I bring this up a fourth time, but I keep a folder in my garage toolbox — court dates, mostly, my brother-in-law's and mine — and I know what it takes to move a document like a restraining order anywhere: somebody has to pull it from the clerk's office, somebody has to read it, somebody has to decide whether it belongs in a statement about a smear campaign. That decision, in this case, got made the same week the file surfaced. I only bring the folder up because it's the only way I know how to measure the trip a piece of paper takes — and this one moved fast.

Excuse me — before you go. The story about the restraining order ran on a Thursday. The governor's offer of asylum ran on a Friday. Which came first — the story about their history, or the offer of asylum?

“They want you looking at one brave holdout getting badgered by eleven jurors, and they need you looking at that before you clock that this same person has a restraining order of their own on file. That's not asylum, that's cover, and Florida's governor built it in about one business day. The actual case — a mother, three dead kids, still no verdict — doesn't get that kind of speed from anybody.”
Sal
“Look, the Governor is simply defending due process for a private citizen who got doxxed for doing his civic duty — his, did I say his? I don't actually know that, forget it, for doing their civic duty. Any restraining order in their past is a completely separate legal matter with nothing to do with this case, which is exactly why we keep bringing it up in the same statement.”
Chip

The receipts

Clancy Juror Appears To Admit Jurors Used Outside Expertise To Badger Holdout The court let a verdict stand after jurors broke the rules
The Federalistright§

Several jurors in the Lindsay Clancy trial appear to have openly admitted to violating jury instruction by using their own experience to make their decision on a verdict while deliberating. In an exclusive interview with NBC 10, a handful of the female jurors who voted to acquit Clancy bemoaned the lone male holdout. The jurors, […]

DeSantis: 'Florida will provide asylum' to holdout juror in Lindsay Clancy case
The Hillmainstream§

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (R) on Friday accused the media of launching a smear campaign against the lone holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial, after a report revealed that the juror had a history of alleged domestic violence and an active restraining order. “A man objected to allowing a woman to kill her...

· Single holdout juror preventing unanimous verdict in Lindsay Clancy trial, defense claims from the morgue, 3 Sep 2026

· Livestreaming Trials Emboldens Lawyers Like Lindsay Clancy’s To Act Out For Clicks from the morgue, 4 Sep 2026

· Three jurors in Lindsay Clancy murder trial speak out in exclusive new interview from the morgue, 8 Sep 2026

· Lindsay Clancy Case: Judge to Question Holdout in 11-1 Jury from the morgue, 4 Sep 2026

· Lindsey Clancy jurors speak about holdout, saying he had ‘reasonable doubt’ from the morgue, 9 Sep 2026

This page is a back-issue: the story as it ran, receipts as they were. The current edition is at the front.