“Israeli UN ambassador criticizes Mamdani as too ‘clever’ for his own good: ‘You cannot set the fire, then say this’”, 18 September 2026 (Photo via New York Post — the original report)
As it ran on the front
The mayor of New York said it again this week. Benjamin Netanyahu should be arrested when he lands here for the General Assembly, Zohran Mamdani said, because what has been visited on Palestinians is a genocide and the man is a war criminal. Say what you like about the timing. He said it on the record, with his name attached, about a head of government who will be standing at a podium on his island in a matter of days.
The answer came back on September 17, and it did not come from a New York cop or a federal prosecutor. It came from Israel's ambassador to the United Nations, who proposed a swap: "If someone should be arrested, it's Mayor Mamdani for inciting, for actually collaborating with the enemy of the United States." A foreign envoy, standing in this country, naming the elected mayor of its largest city a collaborator. Not the argument that the mayor is wrong. The argument that the mayor belongs in a cell.…
…(cont) By the next day the register had softened. Now the mayor was merely too clever for his own good, fanning flames and then acting as if he hadn't — "You cannot set the fire, then say this." And by today the envoy's frame in The Hill is tidier still: the critics are opportunistic politicians, the polling is skewed, the lawmakers are "looking for headlines," because "today it's very easy to get headlines when you attack" Israel.
Here is what a headline was doing on September 16. In Gaza City, an apartment building already wrecked by bombardment came down before dawn and killed at least 21 people, with at least eight children among the dead and dozens trapped under the rubble. Nearly three years of bombardment have left tens of thousands of Palestinians with no choice but to live in an estimated 2,000 buildings in that condition. Common Dreams calls the assault US-backed. That is the wire's word, and it is the only word in this story that tells you whose flag is on the paperwork.
A new film from The Bullet argues the slaughter of civilians there was calculated and intentional — not weather, not accident, a decision with people behind it. That is the claim on the table. And the counterclaim on the table is that a mayor said an impolite thing during UN week.
So count what each man is asking for. One is asking that a government answer for what its army did. The other is asking that a mayor answer for what he said. Either way, the man at the center gets his podium.
🍺
“Watch the swap: a mayor makes an accusation about what a government's army did, and the answer isn't a denial, it's a demand that the mayor be taken into custody for talking. That's not a rebuttal, that's a bill of costs for the sentence — and the envoy's own line is that it's "very easy to get headlines" attacking Israel. What wasn't getting headlines was a bombed-out building in Gaza City coming down before dawn on at least 21 people, at least eight of them children.”
“Nobody is arresting a mayor, it was a rhetorical point, and frankly a fair one — did I call it rhetorical? That doesn't sound like me. Look, the ambassador said what half of America is thinking, the polling on this is skewed, these politicians are chasing cameras, and if you don't care for the temperature, take it up with the man who called a head of government a war criminal during General Assembly week.”
Israel’s UN ambassador Friday slammed socialist Mayor Zohran Mamdani for fanning the flames of anti-Israel sentiment before next week’s General Assembly meeting — only to now act as if he never did.
In the face of growing hard-line opposition to Israel’s government in the United States, the country’s top envoy to the United Nations dismissed criticism against his country, instead blaming opportunistic politicians and skewed polling. “Those lawmakers, I think they are looking for headlines. And unfortunately, today it's very easy to…
Israel’s ambassador to the United Nations called for the arrest of New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani on Thursday ahead of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s visit to the United States next week. The Israeli diplomat’s remarks came in response to Mamdani’s desire to arrest Netanyahu when he is in New York City for the […]
Mayor Zohran Mamdani renewed his call for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to be arrested for war crimes and accused him of visiting a “genocide” on Palestinians just days before the leader is to speak at the UN General Assembly.
This page is a back-issue: the story as it ran, receipts as they were. The current edition is at the front. The byline is a pen name for a column drafted by a machine and checked by the editor: how this is made.