From§Each

Page B1From§Eachthe matinee edition — 28 September 2026

Supreme Court blocks Trump's mail voting plan again, then clears his citizenship check for the same midterms

“SCOTUS Greenlights Use of Federal Citizenship Tool to Vet Voters”, 28 September 2026 (Photo via Truthout — the original report)

As it ran on the front

I found the page where I'd written the same word twice — allowed, blocked, blocked — and I wanted the order read back before I said anything else, if you don't mind.

I keep the notebook in the glovebox, have since the car needed its first fan belt, and most weeks what's in there is oil-change reminders and a grocery list I never buy from. This week it's something else. On September 5th I wrote down that an appeals court kept its foot on the federal citizenship-verification tool — the one that pulls Social Security numbers to check who's allowed to vote — and told Homeland Security it couldn't reopen that door yet. Blocked. I underlined it, I don't know why.…

…(cont) Nine days later, September 14th, a different case, same building. The Court declined again. That's the plan blocked a second time now, same effort, same nine seats. Two conservative justices dissented; I wrote their names down and then crossed them back out, because that's not the part I keep coming back to.

Then last week — I have to flip forward to find this one, it's near where I started keeping receipts from the corner store, don't ask — the same Court let the citizenship tool proceed. Truthout called it a rare victory for the administration's push to put more federal hands on how the country runs its own elections. Cleared. Same building, different door.

Here's a thing I do most mornings that I think about now. There's a toll plaza on the way into town with two lanes, one for the transponder and one where you stop and hand somebody cash. Same road, same car, same driver — I go through whichever lane's open, and I've never once thought there was a reason one lane moves and the other doesn't, beyond which one happened to be staffed that day. I don't go looking for a pattern in a toll booth. Should I be looking for one at a building where a mail-in ballot plan gets turned back a second time and a citizenship-verification tool gets waved through the same month?

ProPublica went and found where the mail-in restriction actually came from — traced its origins, they said, before it was ever a plan on a docket. I read that piece again before I trusted it, and wrote down origins with a question mark next to it, because I wanted to know what a thing looks like before it's a thing.

Oh — before you go. The Times ran a retrospective this week too, cataloguing what they called the president's most durable lie: rigged, fraud, hoax, the same word attached to elections for years now, older than anything else in my notebook. I wonder whether that's the word sitting under the block and the second block and the clearance alike — the same claim about a rigged vote used to justify stopping one thing and freeing another. Is that the word doing the work both times, or is it just a word I keep finding twice?

“Same court, same month, same guy's claim about a rigged election underneath both rulings — they use it to choke off mail ballots and to wave through a tool that checks up on who gets to vote at all. That's not two stories, that's one lever with two ends, and only one end helps you vote easier. Watch which lane stays open next time they say the count can't be trusted.”
Sal
“Look, these are two completely separate legal questions with two completely separate records — you can't just mash a citizenship-verification ruling and a mail-ballot case together because they happened near each other on a calendar. The Court sided with the law both times, that's — did I say "sided with the law both times"? I mean it ruled on the merits each time, separately, obviously.”
Chip

Earlier in this story

The receipts

· Appeals Court Maintains Block on Federal Voter Identification Tool from the morgue, 5 Sep 2026

· Supreme Court won’t restore Trump’s mail-in voting plan for midterms from the morgue, 14 Sep 2026

This page is a back-issue: the story as it ran, receipts as they were. The current edition is at the front. The byline is a pen name for a column drafted by a machine and checked by the editor: how this is made.