John Nichols Even before her state botched another execution, gubernatorial candidate Jerri Green was telling Tennesseans that “the death penalty has always been inhumane, expensive, and biased.” The post The Moral Clarity of Tennessee Gubernatorial Candidate Jerri Green appeared first on The Nation .
Page A5From§Eachthe late evening edition — 5 October 2026
Pentagon approves firing squad days after the drug meant to kill Christa Pike left her alive forty minutes.

As it ran on the front
I made a list. There was too much this week to keep straight any other way, so I wrote it down, in order, the way it happened, and I'm just going to read it to you. Then I'm going to stop.
October 1: Tennessee's governor says it's "deeply disturbing" that his state botched an execution — a woman who stayed alive and snoring forty minutes after a double dose of the drug that was supposed to kill her quickly. He suspends every execution in the state until at least the end of the year.…
…(cont) October 2: her lawyer says she's in critical condition. The governor orders an independent inquiry into what happened.
Days after that: the man running Tennessee's prisons — the one who came in with four botched executions already on his record from his last job — resigns.
Same week: a man named Gary Wayne Sutton, on death row for killing the man who bailed him out of jail, has his December execution date put on hold. Nobody found anything new wrong with his case. The execution team just isn't trusted to run one right now.
October 6: the Pentagon approves a request to execute Nidal Hasan, the Fort Hood shooter, by firing squad. First time the military's done that in decades.
That same morning, a paper out of Houston runs a piece calling the death penalty "legalized torture by the government."
That's the list.
I've got a toolbox in the garage, nothing special, a torque wrench I bought because the manual said to tighten the lug nuts to a specific number or the wheel comes off down the road. Precise tool. Does one job. When it stops reading right — and it does, eventually, they all do — I don't reach for a bigger wrench and lean on it harder. I take it in, or I replace it. The whole point of a torque wrench is that it's supposed to be exact. A sledgehammer's under the same bench. I use it for things that are already broken and need to come apart. I have never once reached for the sledgehammer because the torque wrench was reading low.
So here's what I don't follow. Tennessee's precise method — the one that's supposed to measure out exactly enough to do the job quietly, quickly, a double dose, nothing left to interpretation — didn't do the job. It did something nobody planned for, in front of witnesses, and the governor used the word "disturbing" about his own state's hand. That's this month. And this same week, a different part of the same government signs off on the blunt method. The one with no dose to calibrate. First time in decades anybody's authorized it.
The governor's statement — the one calling his own state's work disturbing — is dated October 1st. The Pentagon's approval of the firing squad is dated October 6th. Five days apart. I can hold both pieces of paper in the same hand. Which one happened first?
Which brings me to the last thing on the list, and then I really will let you go.
That piece out of Houston calls the death penalty "legalized torture by the government." I don't know what the writer was looking at when they picked that word. Could've been nothing but what happened in Tennessee this month.
Oh — one more thing, before I go. Is "torture" the word the paper in Houston reached for on its own, or is it just the plain word for a drug that's supposed to kill a person quickly instead leaving her breathing on the table long after it should have worked, while the man in charge of the state calls it "disturbing"?
“They can't keep a lethal injection working for forty minutes without a woman ending up in critical condition, so the fix isn't fixing the drug — it's switching to a method that can't fail in a way anybody has to write a report about. Same week, they sign off on a firing squad for the first time in decades. Houston called it torture; I'd just call it bookkeeping — pick the method that doesn't leave a mess for the inquiry to clean up.”
“This has nothing to do with what happened in Tennessee — the Hasan case has been moving through review for years, and a firing squad is simply the more reliable method for a military execution. Reliable, meaning it doesn't involve a dose you can get wrong, unlike — did I say "get wrong"? That's not a word I'd use about a state's own process. Two completely separate decisions, same week, pure coincidence.”
Earlier in this story
- Gary Wayne Sutton's execution is on hold because Tennessee's execution team keeps failing, not because his case changed. By Ruth · the early evening edition, 5 October 2026
- CEOs sign accord naming AI 'Super Intelligence,' then refuse to call it that when asked By Mitch · the sunrise edition, 4 October 2026
- Tennessee hired a commissioner with four botched executions, got a fifth, ordered its first review. By Ruth · the sunrise edition, 4 October 2026
- CEOs sign 'morally binding' AI pact that leaves the binding part unnamed By Mitch · the milkman edition, 4 October 2026
- Tennessee hired a chief after four botched executions, got a fifth, named a sixth official to explain it. By Ruth · the wee small hours edition, 4 October 2026
- Tennessee hired a prison chief with four botched executions in the file, got the fifth on Wednesday and the resignation on Saturday; the Justice Department spent the same week asking the judge who struck its press ban to restore it on grounds of professionalism. By Ruth · the midnight edition, 4 October 2026
The receipts
Houston The death penalty is a crime. It is legalized torture by the government. The death penalty must be abolished now, immediately, today!
Pentagon spokesperson Sean Parnell said in a statement that Defense Sec. Pete Hegseth recommended the execution and it was approved by President Donald Trump.
· Christa Pike left in ‘critical condition’ as Tennessee halts all executions from the morgue, 2 Oct 2026
· Tennessee suspends executions as Christa Pike’s lawyer says failed lethal injection leaves her in critical condition from the morgue, 2 Oct 2026
· Tennessee suspends executions as Christa Pike’s lawyer says failed lethal injection leaves her in critical condition from the morgue, 1 Oct 2026
· Tennessee governor suspends executions after ‘deeply disturbing’ failed lethal injection from the morgue, 1 Oct 2026
· In Florida, illegal aliens who commit crimes aren't deported — they're put to death from the morgue, 31 Aug 2026
This page is a back-issue: the story as it ran, receipts as they were. The current edition is at the front. The byline is a pen name for a column drafted by a machine and checked by the editor: how this is made.