“Why a Merciless Supreme Court Rebuke on Election Eve Matters”, 5 November 2026 (Photo via The New York Times — the original report)
As it ran on the front
I will defend this Court on the merits, and the merits are a calendar.
Start with September 14th, which your side never starts with: the justices declined to let the administration enforce its new mail-in ballot restrictions before the midterms. That is the administration losing. Hold on to that.…
…(cont) Then September 25th. Six to three, the Court lifted the lower-court order that had kept the Department of Homeland Security from using and expanding a database called SAVE to screen state voter rolls, and gave the department ninety days to do it. SAVE was built to check whether noncitizens qualified for benefits. It is known for flagging naturalized citizens. It cannot confirm four in ten names. The word is screening. Screening is not purging. Screening is a courtesy.
And the courtesy was capped, which is the part nobody reads. Existing law blocks most states from systematically purging voters inside ninety days of an election, which is why the Associated Press reported the immediate impact on the midterms was likely limited. Limited. Note the two clocks, because they do not run the same direction: the department's ninety days to build the thing counts forward from the order and runs past Election Day, while the ninety days of protection counted backward from Election Day, and Election Day came and went. So the tool is new and the shield is — I would like to come back to that.
Money, briefly, since you will raise it. In September the reporting had one donor planning to spend at least $100 million for Republican majorities, and the critics spent that week rebuking Democrats for declining to make an issue of it. Those are filings. Every dollar disclosed, on the record, by law. The fact that we can count it is the proof the system works, and the count is three hundred sixty-six million dollars, which is not a defense, it is a number, and I said it out loud.
New Hampshire. The state's secretary of state filed an emergency application on October 20th. The Court granted it that Thursday in a brief unsigned order, citing the longstanding rule that lower federal courts should not "alter election rules" too close to Election Day. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented alone, writing that "when an election is looming" she would not disturb a justifiable federal-court order meant to keep the public accurately informed. One of nine. Republicans said the ban was needed to combat fraud. The Federalist called the student card a loophole. Voting-rights advocates said the directive falls on young and low-income voters, who are, let us be precise about this, voters.
Then election eve, and the rebuke. The president asked the justices to step into the election, and they took just hours to reject it. Hours. That is independence and I will stack it against anything you have.
Twelve days for the students. Hours for the president. Ninety days for the database, still running, with nothing counting backward at it now.
And this same Court has not decided whether a person may sue the officer who hurt them.
The Supreme Court considers the case of a prisoner who suffered brutal injuries, only to be denied medical care behind bars. He wants to sue the prison nurse in a case that could change the law on holding federal officers accountable.
This page is a back-issue: the story as it ran, receipts as they were. The current edition is at the front. The byline is a pen name for a column drafted by a machine and checked by the editor: how this is made.