The bill, which will change federal approval processes for fossil fuel projects, is backed by Big Oil and tech giants.
Page F145From§Eachthe afternoon edition — 17 November 2026
21 Democrats called a data center bill 'toothless,' then advanced one critics say guts the Endangered Species Act.

As it ran on the front
Here is the list, read straight through, in the order it happened, and then I will stop. September 30th: Senate Democrats blocked a bill addressing data center electricity costs and called it "toothless." October 1st: The Hill laid out what a different bill, the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, would actually do. October 6th: two hundred environmental groups wrote to lawmakers saying that bill would gut the Endangered Species Act. October 21st: a bipartisan group of former officials sent a letter urging Congress to pass it anyway. October 22nd: an analysis warned the bill would lock in Trump-era approvals for data centers, nuclear facilities, and fossil fuel projects for decades. November 5th: protesters gathered outside Senator Schumer's house in Brooklyn, calling it a "dirty data center deal." November 17th: twenty-one Democratic senators who had voted the first bill down in September crossed over and helped move the second one forward.
That's the whole list. I went over it twice before setting it down here, because I kept expecting one of those seven dates to explain the other six, and I don't think it does.…
…(cont) I should say where I'm coming from, since this isn't the first week this page has looked at this crowd. September 30th, the same day they called the data center bill toothless, Senate Democrats also blocked their own stock trading ban for being too weak. November 4th, the country handed Democrats the House and the Senate both. November 9th, Senator Sanders said the new Congress could use reconciliation — fifty-one votes, no filibuster — as a first step toward Medicare for All. November 13th, Speaker Jeffries talked about lowering the Medicare age. Three weeks after the election, a column on this page pointed out that the reconciliation tool was still sitting unused. I'm only telling you that so you know where I was standing before this week's list showed up on my desk.
So here's where that leaves me. Twenty-one senators voted no on a data center bill in September, in their own word, because it was toothless. Twenty-one senators voted yes on a bigger data center bill in November that two hundred environmental groups say guts the Endangered Species Act. According to the analysis from October 22nd, nothing is — the approvals it locks in are the same approvals, and the warnings about it only got louder in the seven weeks in between.
I've got a pegboard in my garage I don't go into enough. There's a torque wrench on it I've used exactly once, for one job, years ago, and an Allen key set in a size I'm still not sure fits anything I own. My wife asks why I keep them. I tell her I might need them someday. It isn't really an answer. It's just the one I give her.
Oh — one more thing, before I close this up. The same twenty-one senators who said a data center bill was too weak to protect ratepayers in September said yes to a data center bill two hundred groups say is strong enough to gut the Endangered Species Act in November. So what did?
“These are the same twenty-one who said no to a weak data center bill in September because it didn't do enough, then said yes to a bigger one that two hundred environmental groups say guts the Endangered Species Act for Big Oil and Big Tech. Nothing in that bill got better between September and November — the senators did. Watch the number on your electric bill, because the same guys who wouldn't vote for the ratepayers voted for the people building next door to them.”
“Look, this is bipartisan permitting reform, co-sponsored by a Republican and a Democrat both, with former national security officials practically begging Congress to pass it — that's not a fossil fuel giveaway, that's modernizing the grid. Sure, two hundred environmental groups say it guts the Endangered Species Act, but that's just — did I just say "gut the Endangered Species Act" like it's nothing? That's not what I meant to defend.”
Earlier in this story
- Democrats control Congress and a filibuster-proof process, unused even to ban their own stock trading. By The Wrecking Crew · the afternoon edition, 16 November 2026
- Senate Democrats blocked the stock-trading ban October 1; 46 days later 50 incoming Democrats demand one By Lou · the morning edition, 16 November 2026
The receipts
Passing the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act will make Congress members complicit in a massive intergenerational theft.
Protesters are planning to gather outside the Brooklyn home of US Sen. Chuck Schumer on Friday morning, demanding he block what they've dubbed a "dirty data center deal" from passing through the Senate. The bill, known as the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA), is aimed at speeding the permitting process for energy…
Permitting reform talk is dominating D.C. after the Senate took a key step toward advancing legislation. Bipartisan agreement on the need to streamline federal permitting for major energy and infrastructure projects has reached a critical juncture in Washington.
· Democrats block data center bill in Senate from the morgue, 30 Sep 2026
· Analysis Warns Bipartisan Senate Permitting Bill Would Lock In Trump-Era Data Center, Fossil Fuel Approvals from the morgue, 22 Oct 2026
· 200+ Groups Call on Lawmakers to Oppose Permitting Reform That Would Gut Endangered Species Act from the morgue, 6 Oct 2026
· Former officials urge Congress to reform permitting from the morgue, 21 Oct 2026
· What's in the permitting reform bill? from the morgue, 1 Oct 2026
This page is a back-issue: the story as it ran, receipts as they were. The current edition is at the front. The byline is a pen name for a column drafted by a machine and checked by the editor: how this is made.