There is exactly zero reason to believe Chuck Schumer is the man for this moment. Yet most union leaders are not speaking up against him in the fight with Chris Van Hollen for Senate majority leader.
Page A240From§Eachthe evening edition — 18 November 2026
600,000 machinists, the Working Families Party and Bernie Sanders ask Schumer to go; Clinton calls it a performance

As it ran on the front
I had it written down. Hold on a second — it's the spiral one, the wire's bent and it catches on the lining of the coat, that's why this takes me a minute. Here. Wednesday. Sixty-five to thirty-one.
That's the procedural vote advancing the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. Fourteen Democrats voted to advance it, and the Senate minority leader was one of the fourteen. The bill speeds up permitting for energy and infrastructure projects by limiting environmental reviews and restricting the ability to challenge permitting decisions in court. Democratic supporters celebrate it as a way to get clean energy built and bring energy costs down; they point to projections of modest emissions reductions. Environmental groups warn about what else it clears the way for, and an environmental advocate called the same day for him to step down as leader.…
…(cont) Next page over, one word, underlined, because I'm not a clever man about shorthand. That's the former secretary of state, the same day, on Senator Van Hollen's challenge for majority leader. A performance.
I'm sorry to keep the notebook open on you, but the dates are the part I can actually check, so let me do the dates.
Monday the ninth: Our Revolution releases a survey of more than 4,300 progressive activists, and a majority of them want the Senate leader and the House leader replaced. That same Monday night, the Machinists — the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, 600,000 members — their international president, Brian Bryant, sends a letter thanking him for many years of leadership and friendship and asking him to step aside and let "a new generation to lead Senate Democrats."
Tuesday the tenth, Senator Sanders tells reporters he has known Chuck for over thirty years, that he likes Chuck, that "the time is now for change," and that he will not support the bid.
Friday the thirteenth: the Working Families Party writes on behalf of its hundreds of thousands of members "and the working-class people we organize," thanks him for helping pass relief packages, and asks that the party begin a new chapter.
A survey, two letters, and a senator talking to reporters — all of it dated before anybody got near the floor for the vote I wrote down. I apologize for circling, but look at the word from the calendar side: the word lands the eighteenth. The first of those letters is the ninth. Nine days apart. Two Mondays.
Here's the thing that sticks with me, and it's small. Two springs ago I took a clipboard up and down my own block about the streetlight at the corner, the one that's out. Three Saturdays. The dog came along, which cost me time at every hedge. Eleven signatures. Eleven, on one block, for a light eleven of us wanted, and I stood on porches in a raincoat to get them.
Six hundred thousand members is the number in that letter. Somebody had to draft it, somebody had to sign it, somebody had to carry it across a room and set it down in front of him. I'm sorry, I keep going back to this, but I can't get the clipboard and the word to sit in the same hand.
Then Jacobin, this week: most union leaders are not speaking up against him in the fight with Van Hollen for majority leader. So the letters get counted, and the quiet gets counted too.
One more page, and forgive me, it's the word again from underneath. September second, Independence, Missouri: 68 percent of one council district voted to recall a councilman over his vote to approve tax incentives for a data center. Elected to serve through June 2028; out as soon as the results come in. Sixty-eight to thirty-two.
Oh — excuse me, before you get your coat. One thing and I'll let you go. The Machinists' letter is dated the ninth. The vote is dated the eighteenth. Which of those two did the word get hung on — the vote, or the fight the letters are part of? My page only has it next to one of them. A performance.
“They want you to think this is theater class. A 600,000-member union mailed a letter nine days before the floor vote, Sanders said it out loud, the Working Families Party put its members' names on it — and then he helped clear a procedural vote 65-31 on a bill that strips environmental reviews and takes away your right to challenge a permit in court. That's the con: call the people asking for new leadership a performance, and the courthouse door closes while everybody's looking at the stage.”
“Look, it's a bipartisan affordability bill, it builds energy infrastructure faster, it lowers costs, there are projections of emissions reductions — modest ones. Did I say modest? That doesn't sound like me. And as for the leadership business, Secretary Clinton called it a performance, so I'm just agreeing with a Democrat here, which if you think about it is the bipartisan part.”
The receipts
An environmental advocate is calling for Sen. Chuck Schumer to step down as Senate Democratic leader after he supported a permitting reform bill that critics say will empower polluters by weakening environmental regulations. Schumer (D-NY), the Senate minority leader, was one of 14 Democrats who voted Wednesday to advance the Bipartisan…
Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton called Sen. Chris Van Hollen's challenge to Sen. Chuck Schumer for Senate majority leader a "performance."
· Working Families Party Joins Call for Schumer to Step Aside in Senate Leader Race from the morgue, 13 Nov 2026
· Bernie Sanders says he will not back Schumer for Senate Democratic leader from the morgue, 10 Nov 2026
· 600,000-Member Machinists Union Calls on Schumer To Allow ‘A New Generation To Lead’ Democrats from the morgue, 10 Nov 2026
· Majority of Progressive Organizers Want Schumer and Jeffries Replaced With New Leadership from the morgue, 9 Nov 2026
· Voters in Missouri City Overwhelmingly Vote to Recall Councilman Who Approved Data Center from the morgue, 2 Sep 2026
This page is a back-issue: the story as it ran, receipts as they were. The current edition is at the front. The byline is a pen name for a column drafted by a machine and checked by the editor: how this is made.