§96 —
On clean coal
Democrat
37,900
Lazard's July 2026 table prices new coal at $72 to $177 a megawatt-hour, against $51 to $129 for combined-cycle gas, $40 to $98 for utility solar and $37 to $99 for onshore wind. For new coal Lazard cites "limited public and/or observable data" and reuses an old figure adjusted for inflation. An existing plant runs cheaper, $34 to $69 1.
The Environmental Defense Fund's tracker puts six plants under orders at $593 million so far 2. Campbell alone cost a net $259 million through June 30, after a retirement date of May 31, 2025 3. On September 11 the D.C. Circuit vacated the first Campbell order, unanimously; the department has asked for a rehearing, and the order in force on October 30 ran through November 14 34. Coal mining employed 40,500 people in January 2025. The preliminary count for September 2026 is 37,900 5. The plants were kept. The jobs were not on the order.
Sources
- Unsubsidized levelized cost ranges and marginal cost of existing coal; the coal note reads "limited public and/or observable data available for new-build geothermal and coal projects" — Lazard LCOE+, July 2026 ↑
- "Cost to ratepayers incurred so far": $593 million, six plants under orders, data updated October 2026 — Environmental Defense Fund ↑
- Order vacated; retirement date 31 May 2025; "the net cost of complying with the DOE emergency orders was $259 million" through 30 June — Utility Dive, 11 September 2026 ↑
- Unanimous panel; the department seeks panel or en banc rehearing; current order through 14 November 2026 — American Public Power Association, 30 October 2026 ↑
- All employees, coal mining, seasonally adjusted: 40.5 thousand in January 2025, 37.9 thousand in September 2026 (preliminary) — Bureau of Labor Statistics, series CES1021210001 ↑
Republican
CLEAN COAL
Give the adjective its due: it has been to the Federal Register. On April 8, 2025, he signed Executive Order 14261, "Reinvigorating America's Beautiful Clean Coal Industry." The word clean appears twice in it, once in the title and once in the line "Our Nation's beautiful clean coal resources will be critical to meeting the rise in electricity demand." The order does not define it 1.
The case for the plants is a real one. During Winter Storm Fern, the Energy Department says, the Campbell plant in Michigan ran above 650 megawatts every day from January 21 to February 1 2. A cold grid wants a plant that answers. As for clean: on February 6 of this year the EPA delayed deadlines for groundwater monitoring at legacy coal ash sites, and on April 9 it proposed weakening the 2024 standards for them, citing "EPA's commitment to restoring American energy dominance" 3. The ponds got a longer clock. The adjective got the title.
Sources
- Executive Order 14261 of 8 April 2025; "Our Nation's beautiful clean coal resources will be critical to meeting the rise in electricity demand"; the word appears in the title and that sentence, with no definition — Federal Register, 14 April 2025 ↑
- Campbell "operated at over 650 MW every day between Jan. 21 and Feb. 1," per the Energy Department — Utility Dive, 11 September 2026 ↑
- Final rule of 6 February 2026 delaying legacy coal ash deadlines; 9 April 2026 proposal weakening the 2024 standards, with the administrator's statement — Harvard Environmental and Energy Law Program tracker ↑
“My brother-in-law had a furnace he wanted to retire. Say the county tells him no, it's an emergency, keep it lit, and the neighbors get the bill. That's only a furnace. I was reading about the Campbell plant in Michigan. Retirement date, May 31, 2025. Net cost through June of this year, $259 million. I looked in the order for what clean means. I read it twice, I'm slow. Sorry, one thing before you go. Coal mining had 40,500 jobs in January of last year and 37,900 this September. Who exactly is being kept on?”— Lou
“Clean coal. I've met clean and I've met coal. The order is called Beautiful Clean Coal, it uses the word clean twice, and it never says what the word means. You know who doesn't define a word? The guy who needs it to keep working. Then they declare an emergency so a plant can't retire, a court throws out the first order, and the meter keeps running. Six plants, five hundred ninety-three million by one count, and fewer miners than when they started. They don't call that a bailout. They call it beautiful.”
“Clean is a relative term, and relative to the ash pond the coal is spotless, which is why the emergency must continue until a court agrees there is one.”